Author (Year) Country Research Design PEDro Score for RCTs Total Sample Size
|
Methods |
Outcome
|
Akkurt et al. 2017
Turkey
RCT
PEDro=5
N=33
|
Population: Median age: Intervention group=33yr, Control group=37yr; Gender: males=29, females=4; Time since injury=>1mo; Level of injury: C=1, T=22, L=10; Severity of injury: AIS A=19, B=1, C=10, D=3.
Intervention: Participants were enrolled in a 12wk program comparing arm ergometer exercises and general rehab exercises to those that receive only general rehab exercises.
Outcome Measures: Center for Epidemiologic Studies Depression Scale (CES-D) and Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale (HADS). |
1. No intergroup differences were seen in HADS and CES-D. |
Chemtob et al. 2019
Canada
RCT
PEDro=9
N(start)=24
N(end)=22 |
Population: Age=51.64±12.13yr.; Gender: males=16, females=8; Level of injury: paraplegia=24, quadriplegia=0; Level of severity: Not reported; Time since injury=15.45±12.85yr.
Intervention: Participants were randomized to either an intervention or control group. The intervention group received one, 1-hour counselling session per week for 8 weeks via online video chat with the intent to motivate patients to increase their leisure-time physical activity, while the control group continued their regular routine.
Outcome Measures: Patient-Health Questionnaire-9 (PHQ-9). |
1. Small effect sizes were found to favour the intervention group at 6 and 10 weeks for improvements in PHQ-9 score. |
Coulter et al. 2017
United Kingdom
RCT
PEDro=6
NInitial=24, NFinal=21 |
Population: Intervention Group: Mean age: 51.5yr; Gender: males=9, females=7; Level of injury: C3/4–L3; Severity of injury: complete=7, Incomplete=9. Control Group: Mean Age: 48.1yr; Gender: males=5, females=3; Level of injury: C3/4–L3, Severity of injury: Complete=5, Incomplete=3.
Intervention: Intervention Group: an 8wk web-based physiotherapy (2x/wk). Individual exercise programmes were prescribed based on participants’ abilities. Control Group: Usual care.
Outcome Measures: Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale (HADS) |
1. No statistically significant difference between the intervention and control groups on the HADS depression and HADS anxiety subscale scores following the intervention. |
Curtis et al. 2017
Canada
RCT Crossover
PEDro=6
N=22 |
Population: Yoga group (n=10): Mean age=47.9±19.5yr; Gender: Not reported; Level of injury: paraplegia=6, tetraplegia=0, ambulatory/unspecified=4; Severity of injury: complete=2, incomplete/disease-related=8. Control group (n=12): Mean age=54.8±10.1yr; Gender: Not reported; Level of injury: paraplegia=4, tetraplegia=4, ambulatory/unspecified=4; Severity of injury: complete=5, incomplete/disease-related=7.
Intervention: Participants were randomized to a 2x/wk for 6wk Iyengar yoga group or a wait-listed control group.
Outcome Measures: Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale (HADS) |
1. Yoga group had significantly lower scores for depression than the waitlist control group (p<0.05).
2. No differences were found for anxiety by group.
3. Fixed-factor models showed significantly lower HADS scores postintervention compared to preintervention (p<0.05) with time being the main predictor of HADS-D (depression) scores (p<0.05). |
Diego et al. 2002
USA
RCT
PEDro=8
N=20 |
Population: Mean age=39yr; Gender: males=15, females=5; Level of injury: tetraplegia; Time since injury=>1yr.
Intervention: One group received a 40 min massage 2x/wk for 5wk by a massage therapist while the other was taught a range of motion exercise routine that they performed 2x/wk for 5wk on their own.
Outcome Measures: State Trait Anxiety Inventory (STAI), Center for Epidemiologic Studies Depression Scale (CES-D). |
1. On pre-posttreatment days, the massage group had lower anxiety scores than the range of motion exercise group (p < .01)
2. On pre-post intervention assessments, the massage groups had greater decreases in depression scores compared to range of motion exercise group (p < .05). |
Hicks et al. 2003
Canada
RCT
PEDro=8
NInitial=43 NFinal=32 |
Population: Age=19-65yr; Time since injury=1-24yr.
Intervention: Experimental group participated in a progressive exercise training program twice weekly for 9mo on alternative day’s 90-120 min starting with warm up, upper extremity stretching, and 15 to 30 min of aerobic training. As the rate of perceived exertion decreased, workload was increased. Some resistance training took place.
Outcome Measures: Centre for Epidemiological Studies Depression Scale (CES-D). |
1. Exercisers reported significantly fewer depressive symptoms than the controls. (p<0.05). |
Latimer et al. 2004
Canada
RCT
PEDro=6
NInitial=34, NFinal=21 |
Population: Intervention group: Mean age: 38.27yr; Gender: males=3, females=8; Level of injury: Tetraplegia=7, Paraplegia=4; Severity of injury: ASIA A=5, ASIA B=1, ASIA C=3, ASIA D=1; Mean time post-injury: 10.54yr. Control group: Mean age: 43.08yr; Gender: males=2, females=8; Level of injury: Tetraplegia=3, Paraplegia=7; Severity of injury: ASIA A=3, ASIA B=1, ASIA C=3, ASIA D=3; Mean time post-injury: 14.58yr.
Intervention: Intervention group: 9mo exercise program – 2d/wk, small group exercise sessions, 60-90min duration consisting of stretching, arm ergometry & resistance exercise with student volunteer personal trainers. Control group: Asked to continue normal daily activities and not begin an exercise routine within 9mo although provided with an opportunity for education.
Outcome Measures: Center for Epidemiological Studies Depression Scale (CES-D). |
1. Exercise group had lower depression than the control group. (p<.05) |
Martin Ginis et al. 2003
Canada
RCT
PEDro=6
NInitial=34 NFinal=34 |
Population: Mean age=8.6yr; Gender: males=23, females=11; Mean time post injury: 10.4yr.
Intervention: Intervention group: 5min of stretching, 15-30min of aerobic arm ergometry exercise & 45-60min of resistance exercise, 2d/wk, in small groups. Control group: Asked to continue normal daily activities and not begin an exercise routine for 3mo
Outcome Measures: Center for Epidemiologic Studies Depression Scale (CES-D). |
1. After 3 months, when compared to controls, exercisers had decreased depression (p=0.02). |
Alajam et al. 2020
USA
Pre-Post
NInitial=15, NFinal=11 |
Population: SCI; Mean age= 38±10yr; Gender: males=8, females=3; Level of injury: T3-L1; Mean time post-injury: 8.72±10.40yr.
Intervention: Participants received walking training, 3 sessions/wk for 8wk. Participants were trained on a treadmill using a novel assistive gait training device consisting of a thigh brace attached to a pulley cable designed to assist with leg flexion.
Outcome Measures: Depression Anxiety Stress Scales-21 (DASS-21). |
1. Statistically significant decrease in mean scores for depression (2.36 point decrease, p<0.01), anxiety (1.45-point decrease, p<0.05), and stress (2.09-point decrease, p<0.01) after training. |
Allin et al. 2020
Canada
Pre-Post
Ninitial=11
Nfinal=10 |
Population: Age=43±8yr.; Gender: males=4, females=7; Level of injury: paraplegia=5, tetraplegia=3, not reported=3; Level of severity: Not reported; Time since injury=20±12yr.
Intervention: Participants took part in a self-paced, six-session self-management program guided by a trained peer health coach. The program lasted between 35-88 days with a total of 6 coaching sessions.
Outcome Measures: Personal Health Questionnaire Depression Scale [PHQ-9]) |
1. PHQ-9 scores decreased, showing improvements, but did not reach significance (p=0.27). |
Crane et al. 2017
USA
Pre-Post
NInitial=89 NFinal=45 |
Population: Mean age=43.8±15.3yr; Gender: males=34, females=11; Level of injury: Paraplegia=11, Tetraplegia (C1-C4)=4, Tetraplegia (C5-C8)=8, Other=22; Severity of injury: AIS A/B=23, C/D=22.
Intervention: Participants engaged in a 3mo physical therapy group exercise class, twice per wk.
Outcome Measures: Patient Health Questionnaire-2 to assess depressive mood |
1. Total depression scores were significantly lower at post-intervention assessment (p<0.05). |
Guest et al. 1997
USA
Pre-Post
N=15 |
Population: Traumatic complete paraplegics; Gender: males=12, females=3; Mean age=28.8yr; Mean time post injury=3.8yr.
Intervention: Electrically stimulated walking program-32-sessions, using the Parastep® FES ambulation system.
Outcome Measures: Beck Depression Inventory (BDI). |
1. BDI decreased after electrically stimulated walking (p<0.05). |
Hicks et al. 2005
Canada
Pre-Post
N=14 |
Population: Chronic incomplete SCI: N=14; Tetraplegic=11, Paraplegic=3; Gender: males=11, females=3; Age range=20-53yr; Mean time post injury=7.4yr; ASIA: B=2, C=12.
Intervention: Body weight supported treadmill training (BWSTT) – up to 45 min, 3x/week, 144 sessions (12mo).
Outcome Measures: Center for Epidemiologic Studies Depression Scale (CES-D). |
1. No change in depression or perceived health (p>.05). |
Kennedy et al. 2006
United Kingdom
Pre-Post
N=35 |
Population: Gender: males=30, females=5; Age: 18-61yr, Level of injury: paraplegia=20, tetraplegia=15.
Intervention: ‘Back-Up Trust’ sports participation program: 1wk participation in single or multi-activity course in an integrated, residential environment. Activities include skiing, horseback riding, waterskiing, canoeing, rappelling and gliding. Questionnaires were completed at baseline and end of 1wk activity courses
Outcome Measures: Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale (HADS). |
1. HADS scores demonstrated significant (p<0.01) improvement in anxiety levels but not in depression levels over the duration of the course. |
Martin Ginis & Latimer 2007
Canada
Pre-Post
N=14 |
Population: SCI; Mean age: 28.8yr; Gender: males=11, females=3; Level of injury: incomplete, ASIA B and C; Mean time since injury: 7.4yr; Chronicity: chronic.
Intervention: Participants performed three exercise sessions of body weight supported treadmill training (BWSTT). Each exercise session consisted of three separate bouts of BWSTT. Depending on the participant’s tolerance, each bout lasted from 5 to 15 min with a 10 min rest between bouts.
Outcome Measures: Profile of Mood States (POMS), |
1. Participants showed a nonsignificant small-to-medium sized improvement in the POMS in session 1, and a nonsignificant decrease in the POMS in session 2 and 3 (p>.05). |
Shem et al. 2016
USA
Pre-Post
NInitial=26, NFinal=10 |
Population: SCI; Mean age: 49.8±13.0yr; Gender: males=14, females=12; Level of injury: tetraplegic=16, Level of injury: paraplegic=6, unknown=4, Mean time post-injury: 25.1yr.
Intervention: Participants completed a 12-week seated Tai Chi course consisting of weekly sessions (one 90-min session/wk).
Outcome Measures: Beck Depression Inventory–II (BDI–II) |
1. No changes in the long-term effect surveys of BDI between the first and the last sessions were observed. |
Warms et al. 2004
USA
Pre-Post
N=16 |
Population: Gender: males=13, females=3; Mean age=43.2yr; Mean time post injury=14.4yr.
Intervention: “Be Active in Life” program: included educational materials (2 pamphlets, 2 handouts), a home visit with a nurse (90 min. scripted motivational interview, goal and personal action plan establishment), and follow up calls at day 4, 7, 11 & 28 (approx. 8 min each). Program lasted for 6wk, and had a final follow up 2wk post-completion.
Outcome Measures: Center for Epidemiologic Studies Depression Scale (CES-D) |
1. No significant change in depression was observed (p>0.05). |
Foreman et al. 1997
Australia
Observational
N=121 |
Population: Sport participants (n=54): Mean age: 31.93±8.23yr; Mean age at injury: 21.02±7.09yr; Gender: males=49, females=5; Level of injury: C=21. Non-sport participants (n=67): Mean age: 38.34±9.25yr; Mean age at injury: 25.02±9.40yr; Gender: males=53, females=14; Level of injury: C=45.
No Intervention: Individuals completed a set of questionnaires including requests for demographic information and assessments of depression and anxiety. Groups were sport and non-sport participants.
Outcome Measures: Centre for Epidemiological Studies Depression Scale (CES-D), State Tait Anxiety Inventory (STAI). |
1. No significant differences were found for depression between the groups (p=0.099).
1. Non sport participants had a significantly higher score in trait anxiety than sport participants (p=0.048). |
Gioia et al. 2006
Italy
Observational
N=137 |
Population: SCI: Mean age: 34.21±11.36yr; Gender: males=137, females=0; Time since injury: 5-10yr; Level of Injury: C5 or below; Neurological status: paraplegic=85; tetraplegic=52.
No Intervention: Wheelchair users were recruited to investigate whether sports activity is associated with better psychosocial outcomes. Participants were divided into a high activity and no activity group.
Outcome Measures: State-Trait Anxiety Inventory (STAI), Questionnaire for Depression. |
1. ANOVA showed that there was a significant main effect of participation is sports on psychological outcomes, with less active people scoring higher in anxiety and lower in extraversion (p<0.05).
2. Anxiety effectiveness was found to positively correlate with sport activity (p<0.01). |
Jorgensen et al. 2017
Sweden
Observational
N=122 |
Population: Mean Age=63±9yr; Gender: Males=86, Females=36; Level of Injury: C1-L5; Severity of Injury: AIS A-C=62, D=60; Mean Time Since Injury=24±12yr.
No Intervention: Not applicable. Review of data from the Swedish Aging with Spinal Cord Injury Study to assess the presence of depressive symptoms among older adults with long-term spinal cord injury.
Outcome Measures: Geriatric depression scale-15 (GDS-15), sense of coherence scale, spinal cord lesion-related coping strategies questionnaire, physical activity recall assessment for people with SCI (PARA-SCI). |
1. Sense of coherence, the coping strategy acceptance, neuropathic pain and leisure-time physical activity explained 53% of the variance in depressive symptoms. LTPA had a significant, negative relationship with depressive symptoms |
Kim et al. 2020
Korea
Observational
N=103 |
Population: Mean Age=36.71±9.77yr; Gender: Males=91, Females=12; Level of Injury: Cervical=59, Thoracic=39, Lumbrosacral=5; Severity of Injury: AIS A=58, B=36, C=7, D=2; Time Since Injury>1yr.
No Intervention: Cross-sectional analysis to assess the relationship between physical activity levels and mental health in individuals with SCI.
Outcome Measures: Godin Leisure-Time Exercise Questionnaire (GLTEQ), Patient Health Questionnaire-9 (PHQ-9), Generalized Anxiety Disorder-7 (GAD-7). |
1. Participants that were the most physically active experienced less depression (PHQ-9; p<0.001) and anxiety (GAD-7; p<0.001) than those who were the least physically active.
2. Multivariate linear regression analysis showed that reduced physical activity was a significant predictor of depression (p=0.01) and anxiety (p=0.02). |
Muraki et al. 2000
Japan
Observational
N=169 |
Population: Mean age:42.7yr; Gender: males=169; Level of injury: Tetraplegia=53, Paraplegia=116; Mean time post-injury: 9.23yr.
No Intervention: Questionnaire. Participants were divided into four groups according to their frequencies of sports activity; High-active (more than three times a week; n=32), Middle-active (once or twice a week, n=41), Low-active (once to three times a month, n=32), and Inactive (no sports participation, n=64).
Outcome Measures: Questions about the frequency and mode of physical activities, Self-rating Depression Scale (SDS), State-Trait Anxiety Inventory (STAI) and Profiles of Mood States (POMS). |
1. Significant differences in depression (SDS), trait anxiety (STAI), and depression and vigor (POMS) among the groups (p<0.05)
2. High-active group showed the lowest scores of depression and trait anxiety, and the highest score of vigor among the four groups.
3. There was no significant difference for any psychological measurements among modes (wheelchair basketball, wheelchair racing, wheelchair tennis and minor modes; (p>0.05). |
Sweet et al. 2013
Canada
Prospective
N=395 |
Population: Age=45.68±14.05yr; Gender: males=298, females=95; Level of injury: paraplegia=190, tetraplegia=194; Level of severity: ASIA A=254, ASIA B/C/D=134; Time since injury=13.51±10.35yr.
No Intervention: None – prospective design. Using a prospective design, this study examined potential intermediary constructs linking LTPA and QOL in people with SCI. Drawing from previous literature, a longitudinal structural equation model was developed and tested to determine if depression, functional independence, social integration/participation, and self-efficacy mediate the LTPA–QOL relationship.
Outcome Measures: Leisure Time Physical Activity (LTPA), Depression (Patient Health Questionnaire-9 (PHQ-9). |
1. LTPA was significantly related to depression (PHQ-9).
2. Depression was statistically significant mediators of the LTPA-QOL relationship. |
Tasiemski and Brewer 2011
Poland
Observational
N=1034 |
Population: Mean age: 35.93yr; Gender: males=861, females=173; I Level of injury: paraplegia: 49.8%, tetraplegia: 50.2%; Mean time since injury: 9.78yr.
No Intervention: Questionnaire based study to examine the interrelationships among athletic identity, sport participation, and psychological adjustment
Outcome Measures: Sport participation, involvement in non-sport recreational activities before and after SCI, Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale (HADS). |
1. Being able to practice one’s favorite sport after SCI was associated with lower levels of depression (p<0.001).
2. Team sport participants reported lower anxiety (p<0.005) and depression (p<0.05) than individual sport participants did. |
Tawashy et al. 2009
Canada
Observational
N=49 |
Population: Mean age: 43.7yr; Gender: not reported; Level of injury: Paraplegia=67%; Injury severity: complete=61%; Mean time post-injury: 11.8yr.
No Intervention: Cross-sectional study to evaluate the relationship between physical activity levels and demographic and secondary complications factors that might relate to physical activity participation.
Outcome Measures: Physical Activity
Recall Assessment for People with SCI (PARA-SCI), Centre for Epidemiological Studies – Depression scale (CESD-10) |
1. Higher amounts of mild-intensity activity and total activity were related to less depressive symptoms (p<0.05). |
VanDerwerker et al. 2020 USA Observational
N=1790 |
Population: Gender: males=1324, females=466; Injury: C1-C4 non-ambulatory=175, C5 and below non-ambulatory=1034, Any level, ambulatory=563; Mean time since injury: 13yr.
No Intervention: Participants completed a mail-in self report survey at two time points (mean 3.29yr apart) and study investigated associations between doing planned exercise and probably major depressive disorder.
Outcome Measures: Patient Health Questionnaire- 9 (PHQ-9). |
1. Participants who did planned exercise three or more times per week at T1 had significantly lower odds of probable major depressive disorder at T2 (p=0.0042).
2. Compared to those who had no change, those who worked out more at T2 had significantly lower odds of probable major depressive disorder (p=0.0005) and those who did less planned exercise had higher odds (p=0.005). |